Poverty Reading List

Untouchables book review

Untouchables: My Family’s Triumphant Journey Out of the Caste System in Modern India

by Narendra Jadhav

If you want to understand India and how to be effective in accelerating impact on poverty there, you need to understand the caste (pronounced “cast”) system and how it affects how the vast majority of people think in India.  For outsiders, the caste system is often perceived as a thing of the past. For, wasn’t the caste system abolished when India declared independence from Britain over 50 years ago?

To see the caste system in action, all you need to do is open up any Indian newspaper and turn to the classifieds section for people seeking marriage partners. Almost all of the ads are explicit about the caste system of the ad buyer as well as the caste requirements of the spouse they are looking for. The explicit caste recognition is less front-and-center in other social spheres, but it is very much there under the surface and affecting how people think about themselves and each other.

This book is a biography of a dalit family living through The Great Depression, the India independence movement and up to today. Dalits are also known as the out-castes or untouchables. They are lower than the lower-castes as they are below the caste system. It is a story of triumph and yet a call to continue to fight to break the caste slavery system.

Narenda Jadhav, born in 1953, says that the caste system is still very much in place. It is still in people’s minds and affects how they see the world every day. Jadhav is a very successful economist and is the chief economist for the Reserve Bank of India (India’s central bank.) And Jadhav is a dalit.

Dalit is the more politically correct name for the out-castes or untouchables. These are people who are so low-on-the-totem-pole that they are not even in the caste system. They are lower than the lowest caste and therefore have no caste. This “matters” in India because castes are connected to occupations. For instance, there is the sweeper caste (who sweep streets), the milk caste (who raise animals to produce milk), the merchant caste (who conduct trade), etc. Historically, and still in much of India, people work in their caste occupations hoping to do a good job so that they when they are reincarnated they will move up to a higher caste. You can find out what caste people are from by asking their name.

The problem with the dalits is that they don’t have an association with an occupation type. So they are relegated to the most demeaning type of occupations including picking up cow dung, begging, scavaging and the like. They are treated like dirt by everyone including the lower caste peoples. They are denied education because they are considered too low for it.

In this book, Jadhav shares the story of his parents growing up through the depression era and through the Indian independence movement. His parents, dalits of course, were illiterate, extremely poor who were born in rural India and moved to Mumbai (formerly Bombay.) You get to see inside the lives of a family on the economic edge and without justice. Yet you see their determination to have their children have a better life.

His father, Damu, catches the dream and becomes a follower of Dr. Ambedkar (affectionately known as Babasaheb) who himself a dalit became a central person in defining the constitution of the new, independent India. Through the biography, Jadhav tells the story of how Ambedkar rallied dalits (now estimated at some 400M+ in India) to assert themselves. He first tried to work within the Hindu religious system for equal rights for dalits. He later gave up this approach and led a mass conversion (literally millions of people) of dalits to Buddhism as an act of liberation. Jadhav provides very interesting color commentary on what that looked like from the eyes of an ordinary dalit.

Damu followed through with Ambedkar’s personal recommendation to educate his children in order for them to escape the tyranny of the caste system. Damu followed through on this and many of his children even went on to college and to having prominent roles in the new India.

While I think that Jadhav has done us all a great service by telling this story, I think you must view the unique success of Jadhav (and his siblings) as an anomaly, not the norm. Just like we can find success stories of African-Americans, this doesn’t mean the equality and justice has been and is being served to all African-Americans in the USA [or pick your own example in another context.]

The caste system is, unfortunately, very much alive and well in India today and is a form of slavery as powerful as other slavery systems in history. About 100 years ago, Jotirao Govindrao Phule, wrote a book called Slavery which articules the how the Hindu religion (he calls it Brahminism) initiated and perpetuates the evil caste system in India. Dr. Ambedkar praised this book: “Mahatma Phule, the greatest Shudra of modern India who made the lower classes of Hindus conscious of their slavery to the higher classes and who preached the gospel that for India social democracy was more vital than independence from foreign rule.” That is, Ambedkar, Phule and others believe that the more important independence which India needs is liberation from the oppressive caste system.

7 thoughts on “Untouchables book review

  1. At the time of independence, I am sure there were at least 2 options:1. Totally ignore the caste system in identifying a person (and use economic wherewithal & need)2. Identify people by their caste and figure out which group to help mostEach option has its pitfalls…and the chosen one definitely has institutionalized the caste system beyond compare!Wonder when there will be another opportunity for the country to redefine identity of its people (not as easy as changing ActiveDirectory schema, is it? (;-)).

    Like

  2. I think a 2nd reformation of India is needed similar to the civil rights movement in the 1960’s in the USA. The same kinds of anti-discrimnation and even affirmative action measures are needed to counter-weight and upset the status quo. It needs to “hurt” the privileged castes to continue to oppress the lower and out castes. This movement will need to be led by high caste … brahmins … similar to how white people needed to lead and give their power over to African Americans.

    Like

  3. India has to get rid of the caste system if it is to become a first world developed country and become a global superpower. India has to find a way to ensure that all of its people have a chance to participate in its economy. The caste system is a form a racism and insularity.

    Like

  4. indian caste hatred is nothing but a worst form of aryan imperialism, which divided its own society to rule and enjoy the fruit of end labour by suppressing humanity through idealistic means, which can only be tackled through materialistic means people should have right to enjoy their labour either it is itellectual or manual, one can’t be suppressed on the name of fake race and colur.

    Like

  5. Surprisingly,Indian Caste system is such a disease which engulfs entire territory of India.It is a total killer for the one sixth population of india known as dalits which are reeling under its devastating effects.Even today in India,it is caste which rules over the minds of the people,more so in rural India.Under Indian Caste system,it is the birth which rules over the worth even today.

    Like

  6. I’m going to look this up. Untouchability is still a massive problem of course and the time has come for another Gandhi to really make it a national issue again. The rise of so called ‘Dalit-lit’ must be a good thing though

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s